God and the Pandemic.
Tom
Wright (formerly Bishop of Durham) has written an excellent book which I
thoroughly recommend. These notes are a
short summary of the book, with a few of my own thoughts included.
Supporting 'the family'
In ancient times when a
disaster happened, people assumed that the gods were angry and needed to be
appeased. They usually tried to placate
the gods by sacrifice - in some pagan religions they would even sacrifice their
own children. Any support they gave to
one another would be most likely within their own extended family. But there was no concept of supporting the
community at large.
One of the great steps forward brought about by
Christianity was that believers in Jesus tried to follow his teaching by
supporting one another as a Christian family in hard times. Thus the concept of 'family responsibility'
was extended from blood relations to the Christian community at large. Jesus reached out to help people, even before
they became believers. There is no
recorded instance, for example of Jesus turning away someone who sought
healing. When he fed the 5000, no-one was excluded from the meal. So Christians followed this example too,
feeding the hungry, giving a drink to the thirsty, clothes to the needy,
visiting the lonely and the imprisoned.
They did this, and still do so, following Galatians 6.10: So
then, while we have opportunity, let us be working good to everyone, but
especially to the family-members of the faith. Our heritage from this today includes
hospitals and schools, as well as numerous Christian charities supporting the
poor and needy, and those afflicted by disasters, irrespective of whether the
needy are themselves Christian, though the first responsibility of a Christian
is to fellow-believers.
In
the current pandemic, sorrow is arising from the whole world like a pall of
smoke and we hardly dare ask the question 'Why'? Actually the best
answer has been not to the question 'Why?' but to the question 'What can we
do?' When the government asked for people to help the NHS as volunteers, half a million
people signed up almost at once. They were doing what Christians have done over
the centuries in times of disaster. Christians copy Jesus in supporting the
poor the needy and the sick. In Britain
and other countries with Christian roots people have followed these inherited
principles, though many nowadays have dropped the religious bit. No
matter; the response has been heartwarming.
Inappropriate Christian responses.
Some
Christians have jumped to the conclusion that the pandemic is a sign of the end
times. Others have thought that it is a wonderful opportunity to get people to
think about heaven. And yet others think that God has brought disaster upon us
in order to get us to repent of our evil ways. This follows the simplistic
idea that good things happen to us when we're good, and bad things happen as a
punishment when we're bad! Life, however, is not as simple as that.
A look at the Old Testament
if we look at the Old Testament we might get the impression from
the Babylonian exile that the people of Israel were being punished for
their evil ways. And indeed they were. But this was due to a specific covenant
relationship between God and Israel.
The nation had disobeyed God. They had been warned and had ignored the
warnings. Exile was the outcome. There are plenty of other examples in the Old
Testament of bad behaviour resulting in a bad outcome and good behaviour being
rewarded by a good outcome.
Nevertheless the Old Testament operates at two different levels.
Many of the Psalms include cries of distress by decent people who wonder why
bad things are happening to them. Moreover the book of Job - perhaps one of the
most ancient parts of the Old Testament - is a story describing bad things
happening to a good man. His friends come to entirely the wrong conclusion by
believing that his ill-fortune is a result of bad behaviour or sin. The story
has a happy ending, but is only partially resolved. What is absolutely clear
though is that Job's sufferings are brought upon him by a dark power which
has nothing to do with his sinfulness. We do not understand that dark power
whom we call Satan. We are at liberty to cry out in distress if we too suffer for no apparent
reason - as did the psalmists many times, and as did Jesus himself as he
approached his crucifixion. But the
story of Job tells us clearly that the power of evil was only allowed to go as
far as God permitted - and God had his reasons for this which may often be beyond
our understanding.
Jesus and the gospels
The arrival of Jesus on the scene was a turning point in history. Now everything was going
to be different. The Kingdom of heaven was at hand. in some ways Jesus was like
the Old Testament prophets: warning people that unless they changed their ways
and repented disaster would come, as indeed it did when the Romans devastated Jerusalem 40 years
later.
But in another way Jesus was not like the Old Testament
prophets. When asked for a sign, he usually refused to give one on demand. The
only sign he would give them was the prophetic sign of Jonah. Jonah disappeared
into the belly of the whale and then came out alive three days later and Jesus
said that was the sign that would tell his generation what was going on. (It's
recounted in Matthew 12.40. The sign of
course would be subsequently when he died and returned to life on the third
day.)
In the Old Testament, signs were usually negative ones such as the
great plagues in Egypt.
By contrast the signs that Jesus gave were positive: water into wine, healings,
food for the hungry, sight for the blind, life from the dead.
One thing which Jesus was very clear about was that if a person
suffered it was not necessary to assume that it was a punishment for sin. In
John chapter 9 he was asked about a man who was born blind. 'Teacher, whose sin was it that caused this man to be born blind? Did
he sin or did his parents?' 'He didn't
sin', replied Jesus, 'nor did
his parents. It happened so that God's works could be seen in him.' So Jesus was not looking back to why it
happened but forward to what God was going to do about it. That meant that
Jesus himself was going to do something, which indeed he did by healing the
blind man.
Us. What are we going to
do?
Some Christians may think of the current pandemic as a sign from
God. But we don't actually need signs of this sort from God. The ultimate sign
was Jesus himself, his death and his Resurrection. Jesus gave us what we now
know as the Lord's Prayer. In it he tells us to pray 'thy kingdom come'. He also tells us to pray 'forgive us our sins'. This is all we need. We need to be
Jesus centred, and consider in the light of our faith in Jesus Christ what
we are going to do about the
situation in which we find ourselves in this pandemic. We can and should pray
for forgiveness from our sins. We can and should pray for God's Kingdom to
come. Actually, God's Kingdom has already been inaugurated by Jesus. But the
power of evil has not yet been destroyed and we should seek to let God's power
work through us as we fight against the enemy.
If God is almighty, why
doesn't he intervene and stop the pandemic?
God is sovereign. but if we believe this we have to try and
understand what it means. If God is sovereign why doesn't he stop the pandemic?
Why doesn't he abolish suffering? The story of Jesus and Lazarus is very
instructive here. The sisters of Lazarus blamed Jesus, saying 'If you had been here Lazarus would not have
died.' Jesus himself wept genuine tears at the tomb of Lazarus, weeping
because he knew of the real suffering that had occurred as a result of Lazarus'
death. Yet out of and after the suffering came new life. Jesus himself suffered
on the cross. And sometimes we too will be expected to endure suffering before
we reach the promised land. (I'm reminded of Churchill's speech In June 1940 when he said 'The Battle of Britain
is about to begin. Upon this battle depends the survival of Christian
civilisation. …The whole fury and might of the enemy must very soon be turned
on us. Hitler knows that he will have to break us in this island or lose the
war. If we can stand up to him, all Europe may
be freed and the life of the world may move forward into broad, sunlit
uplands'.) Whilst the power of evil still exists
there will be suffering and we shall be expected to share in this. In Romans
5, Paul suggests that we should rejoice
in suffering. What he means by this is that we should rejoice that our
suffering is not pointless. God will use our suffering to the good purpose of
developing our endurance and our character.
Early believers and their response to disaster.
We can look at the New Testament story to see how early believers
responded to disaster. For example when Agabus in Antioch predicted a worldwide famine,
people did not try to interpret whether it was a sign from God. Nor did they
play the blame game, questioning whether anyone was at fault, or whether the
famine was a punishment for the sins of any group of people. No. Their response
was to consider what they could do about it and whom they could help. They were
fulfilling a principle which was beginning to restore God's Kingdom to the way
it was meant to be. God always wanted to work in his world through loyal human
beings. This is part of the point of being made 'in God's image'.
In the Lord's Prayer we pray 'thy
kingdom come on earth as it is in heaven.' And here already in the early
church we see that Kingdom being launched. The way it is happening is by God
working through people of this sort. And these people are being energized by
the Holy Spirit.
The call to repent is of course a big theme in the New
Testament. But it is not linked to warning signs such as plagues,
famines, or earthquakes. It is linked solely to the Lord Jesus Christ, his
death and Resurrection. This is what Paul carefully taught for example when he
was summoned to the Areopagus High Court in Athens. From the time of Jesus onwards we see
Jesus's followers telling people about God's kingdom and summoning them to
repent not because of any subsequent events such as famines or plagues but
because of Jesus himself. The message was, and is, that Jesus came and died for
our sins, and then conquered death. This is the only sign we shall get. We
should respond by repenting of our sins, giving our lives to Him and becoming
active soldiers in his kingdom. When we
pray 'Thy kingdom come, thy will be done'
we should remember that the Kingdom of heaven is already here and we can be
part of it. There is more to happen yet:
the power of evil is yet to be finally crushed, but God calls us to share with
Him in fighting against this evil.
But why
doesn't God intervene and do something?
During this pandemic there are many people who
are asking why doesn't God do something about it if he is in control?
Now let's ask several questions.
· Why did Jesus weep at
the tomb of Lazarus?
· Why, when we don't know
how to pray as we ought, does the Holy Spirit plead on our behalf with
groanings too deep for words? (Romans 8 27)
· Why did the king of the
Jews hang suffering on a cross?
· Why did God himself the
controller of the universe come in the person of Jesus and show that leadership
involves being a slave being prepared to wash one another's feet?
· And when Peter said to
Jesus 'You shall never wash my feet'
why did Jesus answer 'If I do not wash
you have no part in me?' (John 13:8)
There is something about God being in control
that we need to learn to grasp. And it's to do with suffering and groaning.
It's also to do with true leadership involving servanthood. When there is
suffering, God suffers with us. We see it most clearly in the suffering of
Jesus on the cross. But until the power of evil is fully defeated the whole of
creation will continue to suffer. …...
(Nb my blog entry of May 24th 2020 is on the subject of 'Is God in control?'
Groaning X 3.
Romans 8:22 ESV — For we
know that the whole creation has been groaning together in the pains of
childbirth until now. And not only the creation, but we ourselves, who
have the firstfruits of the Spirit, groan inwardly as we wait eagerly
for adoption as sons, the redemption of our bodies. For in this hope we were
saved. Now hope that is seen is not hope. For who hopes for what he sees? But
if we hope for what we do not see, we wait for it with patience. Likewise the
Spirit helps us in our weakness. For we do not know what to pray for as we
ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep
for words. And he who searches hearts knows what is the mind of the Spirit,
because the Spirit intercedes for the saints according to the will of God. And
we know that for those who love God all things work together for good, for
those who are called according to his purpose.
With creation in an agony of travail during this
pandemic we have no great pronouncement to make about what it all means.
Creation is groaning and so are we. And we are we are reminded in this Bible
passage that God himself is groaning. One Day all this evil will be swept away,
but for the time being God is with us in our grief. Our role is to pray maybe
with wordless prayer and to stand alongside all who suffer.
It's easy for Christians to misunderstand the
meaning of Romans 8 28.
And
we know that for those who love God all things work together for good, for
those who are called according to his purpose.
A a popular interpretation is that in effect we can sit
back and wait for things to come out well because God is going to work all
things for our good. This is rather a stoical way of thinking. 'What will be
will be, and it will all turn out alright in the end.'
But Tom Wright in his book about the pandemic
goes into great detail to show that this is not what the phrase really means. A
much better meaning is that God himself cooperates for good with those who love
God. It reinforces this idea that we are called to hard work and suffering
knowing that God is at work in us. We are called to be part of God's saving
purpose for his suffering world. Paul is not proposing a Christian version of
stoicism. He is offering a Jesus-shaped picture of a suffering redeeming
providence in which God's people are themselves not simply spectators, not
simply beneficiaries, but active participants.
Note that there is one area where God is not
fully in control. This is because he has
delegated a great deal of control to human beings. When they mess up, as is
often the case, he grieves. When Jesus looked at the wickedness of Jerusalem he wept. It is
the price that God paid for making man in his own image.
Where do we go from here?
We must learn that it is right to lament. We are
told to rejoice with those who rejoice and weep with those who weep. The world
is weeping and we should weep with them, as Jesus wept at the tomb of Lazarus.
God is not sending further signs.Jesus himself was and is the sign that we all
need, and if God sent further signs it would imply that the sign of Jesus was
inadequate..
As we lament we must learn to accept that we do
not understand the pandemic and may never understand it. As TS Eliot said "in order to arrive at what you do not
know you must go by a way which is the way of ignorance." Suffice it
to say that all such evils originate with the enemy the devil whose final
defeat has not yet happened. Our role is to fight with Jesus against the enemy
by both prayer and action where possible. God is ultimately in charge and even
though evil stalks the land we can see from the book of Job that Satan, the
author of evil, is limited by God in what he is allowed to do.
Something
which should concern us as church members.
The Christian community has in the past always
been at the forefront of social action to benefit the needy. They have
established schools and hospitals. More recently they have been at the
forefront of hospice care. However, as the years have gone by, the state has
taken over many of these functions; but it would be wrong for Christians to
stand back and think that the only role remaining to them today is to teach
people how to get to heaven! There is always plenty that we can do to
supplement the work of the state authorities and to step in where the state
isn't doing too well
There is a way of thinking which suggests that
religion should be a private matter for the individual and should have no place
in public Life. So worship becomes invisible. There is a danger that in these
days of Zoom meetings this problem will be aggravated. So we should be praying
for the day when our churches can function as they used to do.
The battle
of the false gods - and what we should be hoping and praying for.
Tom Wright imagines a battle going on between
false gods.
Asclepius the god of healing
Mammon the money god.
Mars the god of war
And Aphrodite
the goddess of erotic love is never far away.
Even now there is a tussle between those who
support a total lockdown and those who want to get commerce back on its feet
again. It's a battle between Asclepius and Mammon. And in the background the
superpowers are still building up their armaments and threatening one another.
Meanwhile the poor and the weak will go to the wall again. They always do. It's
a time of lament but it should also be a time of prayer and hope. What we hope
for includes the desire for wise human leadership and initiative which will,
like that of Joseph in Egypt,
bring about fresh and healing policies and actions across God's wide and
wounded world.